Shift in Global Market Focus: Is It Time to Reconsider Indian Stocks Amid China's Stimulus Push?

The Indian stock market has been facing turbulent times recently, with foreign portfolio investors (FPIs) withdrawing over ₹30,000 crore within the first few days of October 2024. Several factors are driving this trend, including geopolitical tensions in West Asia, leading to a sharp rise in crude oil prices, and significant stimulus measures announced by China to support its economy. These events have sparked a debate among global investors—should they continue investing in Indian equities, or is it time to pivot to China?

China's Stimulus and Market Appeal

One of the primary reasons for the shift in investor sentiment is the recent monetary and liquidity measures introduced by China. The Chinese government has been actively rolling out policies aimed at propping up their economy, including fiscal stimulus that has caught the attention of global markets. These developments have made Chinese equities more appealing in the short term, especially when compared to India’s high valuation levels.

According to a report by BCA Research, absolute-return investors are being advised to steer clear of Indian markets in the coming months. They suggest that the stimulus in China presents a more lucrative opportunity, making Chinese stocks more attractive for portfolio managers. With Indian markets sitting at record highs and valuations stretched, analysts believe a correction may be on the horizon, potentially leading to underperformance when compared to China.

Valuation Concerns in India

Indian equities have had a fantastic run, but many experts are now sounding alarms over the overvaluation of Indian stocks. According to analysts from Nomura, India's stock valuations are currently overextended by two standard deviations when compared to historical data. This means that Indian stocks are not only overpriced relative to their own history but also when compared to emerging market peers.

Valuation concerns are coupled with fiscal tightening and credit deceleration in India. BCA Research highlights that both profits and earnings multiples are heading lower, adding pressure to an already strained market. Moreover, with a significant part of India's fiscal spending contracting in nominal terms, it is likely that the country’s economic growth will slow down in the near future. These concerns have led some analysts to recommend a cautious approach to Indian markets, with short-term investments directed elsewhere, particularly in China.

The Global Investor Perspective: India vs. China

China’s markets, on the other hand, are seeing renewed interest due to the combination of low stock valuations and a more promising economic outlook following its stimulus package. Analysts at Macquarie suggest that China's rally will continue to apply pressure on Indian markets. They argue that the slowdown in India, combined with high valuations, might drive global investors toward Chinese equities in the coming months. Liquidity in global markets is being pulled in different directions, and as China’s market gains momentum, India may experience additional outflows.

However, not all analysts agree that this trend will last. Some believe that while China may offer a short-term opportunity, the long-term outlook for India remains promising. Viktor Shvets, head of global desk strategy at Macquarie Capital, mentions that while China’s short-term measures could attract attention, the structural growth story of India still holds more promise in the long run. The challenges facing China, such as high savings rates and policy hurdles, suggest that India’s secular growth prospects are likely to outperform in the years to come.

Is It Time to Exit the Indian Markets?

While some experts are advising a shift towards Chinese equities, others believe that the Indian market’s underperformance will only be temporary. India’s long-term fundamentals remain strong, and as markets adjust to current conditions, there could be a re-entry point for foreign investors. Market corrections, driven by external factors, may actually present a buying opportunity for both foreign and domestic investors in the future.

Ambareesh Baliga, an independent market analyst, suggests that a significant decline in Indian markets could once again make them attractive to foreign investors. He points out that the structural strengths of the Indian economy are still intact, and that investors might return once the market corrects to more reasonable levels. The geopolitical issues and the subsequent flight of capital are temporary setbacks, and the broader outlook for India remains positive.

ALSO READ| Will Foreign Investors Return or Continue Selling in India? Analysts Decode Market Trends

In the end, the choice between Indian and Chinese equities comes down to timeframes and investment strategies. While China may offer short-term gains driven by stimulus, India's long-term growth potential continues to attract investors. Current geopolitical and economic developments have triggered a reassessment of market strategies, but once the dust settles, India is likely to remain an essential part of global portfolios. Investors may want to stay cautious for now, but opportunities could arise as markets stabilize.