Why PSU Rail Stocks RVNL and IRCON Are Falling: Reasons Behind the 7% Q2 Decline

Shares of public sector undertaking (PSU) railway companies, such as Rail Vikas Nigam Ltd. (RVNL) and Ircon International Ltd., have seen significant losses, with RVNL experiencing a 7% drop in its stock price following disappointing financial results for Q2 2024. Despite having growing order books, both companies struggled to deliver the expected earnings growth, leading to a sell-off in their stocks.

RVNL's net profit for Q2 fell by 27% year-over-year, and the company’s revenue dropped slightly by 1.2%, from ₹4,914.3 crore in Q2 2023 to ₹4,855 crore in Q2 2024. In addition to this revenue decline, RVNL also reported a 9% drop in its Earnings Before Interest, Tax, Depreciation, and Amortisation (EBITDA), which amounted to ₹271.5 crore. The company’s EBITDA margin also narrowed from 6% to 5.6%, reflecting the ongoing margin pressure.

These disappointing figures led to concerns about the company’s ability to generate sustainable earnings growth, which in turn triggered a wave of profit booking. Despite growing order books, the inability to convert these orders into higher profits has caused investor sentiment to sour. RVNL, which had seen a significant increase in its stock price earlier in 2024, is now facing a correction, with its stock down by 7% on November 8, 2024.

Prashanth Tapse from Mehta Equities highlighted that, despite a growing order book, the inability to show consistent earnings growth is creating concerns for investors. RVNL’s stock had soared by 150% earlier in 2024 but was unable to maintain those gains due to the underwhelming Q2 results. The 7% drop in RVNL’s stock price was a clear reflection of market disappointment and growing investor caution.

ALSO READ| Why Did Cochin Shipyard’s Stock Fall After Q2 FY24 Results Amid Rising Costs and Lower Margins?

Shares of Ircon also saw a significant drop, with the stock down by 6% following its Q2 results. Ircon’s performance mirrored RVNL’s struggles, with lower-than-expected profits contributing to the overall market decline in railway PSU stocks. Like RVNL, Ircon has a growing order book, but investors are increasingly concerned that these projects are not being converted into sufficient earnings.

The concerns about PSU rail stocks like RVNL and Ircon go beyond the Q2 results. The broader issue is the disconnect between the companies' growing order books and their inability to deliver consistent, profitable results. Investors had hoped that the growing pipeline of orders would result in higher revenues and margins, but the lack of earnings growth has raised doubts about the long-term profitability of these companies.

This situation has led to significant market volatility for PSU rail stocks. RVNL, for instance, had reached an all-time high of ₹647 in July 2024, but after the disappointing Q2 results, it corrected by 30%. Despite this, the stock is still up nearly 150% year-to-date, showing that while the stock experienced a drop, it has still made significant gains in the longer term.

The key issue for investors now is whether these companies can improve their earnings growth in the coming quarters. Both RVNL and Ircon will need to demonstrate that they can turn their growing order books into sustainable profits. If they fail to do so, it is likely that the sell-off will continue, and the pressure on their stock prices will persist.

ALSO READ| Why Jerome Powell Won't Step Down as Fed Chair Even If Trump Asks?

In conclusion, the 7% drop in RVNL’s stock price, coupled with a 6% decline in Ircon’s stock, highlights the growing investor concerns over the lack of earnings growth in the railway PSU sector. Despite strong order books, these companies are struggling to translate this potential into actual profits. Until they can improve their financial performance and deliver on investor expectations, PSU rail stocks are likely to continue facing downward pressure.

[Disclaimer: The information in this article is based on recent financial results and market trends. It does not constitute financial advice. Readers should consult with a financial professional before making investment decisions.]