Senco Gold vs Kalyan Jewellers: Which Jewellery Stock to Pick for Long Term?

As the jewellery market continues to dazzle investors with its robust performance, two key players, Senco Gold and Kalyan Jewellers, have emerged as prime contenders for long-term investment. With their impressive growth trajectories, both companies have sparked interest among investors looking for profitable avenues. However, the crucial question remains: which stock should you consider for sustainable returns?

Recent Performance Trends

In 2024, Kalyan Jewellers has notably outperformed Senco Gold, boasting a remarkable 100% increase year-to-date. In comparison, Senco Gold has also shown strong growth, rising by nearly 84% over the same period. Both companies have managed to deliver positive returns in multiple months, showcasing their resilience and appeal to investors.

Kalyan Jewellers has extended its rally with consistent gains, achieving a notable increase of 6.2% in August and a whopping 29% in June. In contrast, Senco Gold's performance has been marked by significant fluctuations, including a 7% drop in March followed by a 13% gain in January. This volatility highlights the dynamic nature of the jewellery market and the differing trajectories of these two companies.

Financial Health and Market Position

When examining their financial health, both companies have reported substantial year-on-year growth. For Q1 FY25, Senco Gold recorded a net profit of ₹51.27 crore, reflecting a solid increase in revenue. Their consolidated revenue grew by 7.5% year-on-year, bolstered by a significant 61.8% surge in EBITDA.

Kalyan Jewellers, on the other hand, reported an even more impressive performance, with a net profit soaring to ₹177.8 crore, up by 23.6% year-on-year. Their consolidated revenue also grew robustly by 26.5% to ₹5,535.5 crore, demonstrating their ability to capture market share and appeal to a broad customer base.

ALSO READ| Gold Reaches New High Following First Fed Rate Cut Since 2020

Analysts are particularly bullish on both stocks. Motilal Oswal has assigned a "Buy" rating to Kalyan Jewellers, emphasizing its asset-light franchise expansion strategy. Similarly, Senco Gold's strong national presence, especially in the eastern region of India, has positioned it well in the market. They are projected to have a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of around 40% from FY24 to FY26.

Long-Term Prospects: What Investors Should Consider

Investors need to weigh various factors when considering these jewellery stocks. Kalyan Jewellers has demonstrated superior performance in terms of quality and market positioning. It has a more robust brand presence and is currently favoured for its low volatility, which can be attractive during market downturns.

Conversely, Senco Gold presents a compelling value proposition. While Kalyan excels in quality metrics, Senco Gold offers better earnings growth potential. This makes Senco Gold a strong contender for those looking for stocks with high growth trajectories despite facing short-term volatility.

As both companies continue to adapt to evolving market dynamics, investors must keep an eye on their strategic initiatives. Senco Gold’s expansion in West Bengal, where it holds about 4% market share, indicates its potential for growth in untapped regions. In contrast, Kalyan Jewellers' focus on younger audiences and asset-light models positions it well for future scalability.

ALSO READ| BSE Soars: Over 250 Stocks Reach One-Year Highs as Investors Gain ₹6 Lakh Crore

In summary, both Senco Gold and Kalyan Jewellers present unique investment opportunities in the jewellery sector. Kalyan Jewellers may appeal to those seeking stability and established market performance, while Senco Gold offers a more aggressive growth profile. Ultimately, the decision should align with your long-term investment goals and risk tolerance.

[Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is for informational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investors are encouraged to conduct their own research and consult with financial advisors before making investment decisions.]